Saturday, December 12, 2009

Which One?

These are undusted, unprocessed scans of images for my final. The bottom one is a scan of a chromoskedasic mordancage. The top image is the vision i had for this image that I totally ruined, therefore it is a digital composite of a scan of the original chromo (different print than the bottom) and a mordancaged print. Which do you guys enjoy most?

8 comments:

Aly said...

Wow Jace, these both rock!!! The top one is my favorite though. The red is incredibly awesome.

Bek said...

uh oh. bottom one for me. way less contrived.

cool

hunter said...

well they both envoke very different fellings for me...the top one is more powerful and domineering and is probobly my favorite...however the bottom one is more portrait/directorial feeling...i would say because of the strength and power of the top one thats the one i would vote on...i like the extra color and the atmosphere that is brought forward more so than the bottom...

Anonymous said...

Yeah, they have two totally different feelings to them. Go with the one that works with the project better, and if it's a draw I'm a bigger fan of the bottom one. The top immediately jumped out at me as being a little unnatural, so I would only use it if there will be other similar images in the project.

Collin Avery said...

I like the subtlety of the bottom one

Nubia Garcia said...

Bottom one!

Jace said...

Thanx guys. Duly noted.

Jdisney said...

The top one draws its meaning from the red and the bottom one draws its meaning from the figure. It all depends on what message you want to send.
The top has the fire and fury of red. Drawing more anger
where the lower one will draw more somber, sad, reflection, and is more grounded with the earth tone in the background.

So, What do you want the photo to say?